Not all cases that should be won, are won. No one can win 100% of the time; think about it — even the best Major League Baseball players strike out at least 2 out of every 3 at-bats. Most strike out every 3 out of 4 times. Fortunately, I am able to pass through a high percentage of my clients at Stages 1 or 2 of the Disability Retirement process, and that is how it should be.
Every now and again, however, a case must go to the Merit Systems Protection Board; and out of the small number that must get to that point, an even smaller number goes before an Administrative Judge who is clearly anti-employee, and ignores the law and sides with the Office of Personnel Management. Fortunately, most MSPB judges are fair and understand that disability retirement laws favor, for the most part, approval of disability retirement benefits. In those instances where, for whatever reason, a case has been denied at Stages 1 & 2, and the MSPB Judge completely ignores the strong and unequivocal testimony of the doctor, then there is still a good shot at winning the case at the 4th level — a Petition for Full Review.
Such a Stage must be approached by pointing out the legal deficiencies and, indeed, the Hearing Judge’s complete mis-application of the law. It must be done delicately and respectfully, however, because you are essentially asking that the Full Board (a panel of 3 Administrative Judges) reverse one of the Administrative Judges at the Merit Systems Protection Board — to declare that the Administrative Judge “erred” in applying the law. It is possible to do — but it must be done with care, respect, and technical expertise.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Filed under: OPM Disability Process - 4th Stage: Petition for Full Review at the MSPB, The Job of a Federal Disability Attorney, U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) | Tagged: a federal disability attorney that will take your case to the very last, a panel of three administrative judges, an attorney who will represent you during the mspb hearing, appeal to the Merit Systems Protection Board, asking to reverse a mspb hearing judge's ruling is a delicate job, attorney representing federal employees, considering an attorney with experience before the mspb, CSRS disability retirement federal attorney, disability appeal MSPB, federal disability attorney, federal employee attorney, federal injured ill workers, federal workers disability, FERS disability retirement, injured postal worker, job of a postal disability lawyer, lawyer role in federal disability cases, legal & foundational argument, medical evidence, meeting an appeal deadline, Merit Systems Protection Board, Merit Systems Protection Board and OPM disability, misinterpretation or misapplication of OPM disability law, most mspb are fair with regard to opm disability cases, MSPB Administrative Judge, MSPB and OPM disability retirement, mspb attorney, MSPB disability lawyer, MSPB Petition for Review, MSPB Reconsideration Stage, MSPB Third Stage, OPM disability appeal to the MSPB, OPM disability application tips and strategies, OPM Disability Proces 4th (Fourth) Stage, OPM disability retirement, OPM First Stage Disability Application, Petition for Full Review at the MSPB, Petition for Review before the Merit Systems Protection, physician's statements in an OPM disability case, Postal Service employee advocate, Second Step OPM Appeal, the job of a federal disability retirement attorney, USPS disability retirement, when the mspb is clearly anti-employee, when you really need a federal disability retirement lawyer!, workers comp lawyer for postal worker, your treating doctors | Leave a comment »