The traditional philosophical arguments surrounding the nature of Truth, the “battle” between “Absolute Truth” and “Pure Relativism”, etc., are too often simplified and reduced to sloganeering and shouting matches which end up being nothing more than accusations as to whether one believes in a Higher Order of Being — or not. Yet, it is often a perspective upon appearances which determines the “truth” of a statement.
Plato pointed this out in reference to the three towers in the distance; if seen from one direction, they appear to be only one; if seen from another, they constitute 3 distinct objects.
The U.S. Office of Personnel Management, in denying a Federal Disability Retirement application under FERS, takes a similar perspective on truth. They will take each medical condition cited, isolate each and minimize the impact of the separated medical conditions upon one’s ability or inability to perform the essential elements of one’s Federal or Postal position, and by approaching the “truth” this way, can purport to make your case appear “as if” you never had any case at all.
Now, some might critically argue that such an approach is “disingenuous” (i.e., somewhat akin to the “absolutist” argument), while others merely view this as “clever” (i.e., akin to the “relativists”). The point of OPM’s approach is to make you believe that you never had a chance to begin with, and to have you go away without filing for Reconsideration, thus reducing their caseload by a numerical insignificance until multiplied by an exponential factor of greater percentages.
The way to counter OPM’s argument? To identify their approach and counter it with a different, more powerful perspective on truth — by further medical documentation and more powerful legal argumentation which makes OPM’s argument impotent and irrelevant.
For, in the end, a perspective on truth must be countered by proposing an alternative perspective on truth — of showing that the three-towers-in-one is a mere illusion and a trick of the eye.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Filed under: Reflections of an OPM Disability Retirement Lawyer | Tagged: after separation from agency for retirement disability and back pay, agency and light duty status, being on partial disability with owcp v. partial federal disability retirment, bullying law in the federal govt causing severe stress on employees, can a federal employee get medical separation without disability retirement?, can a professional counselor write the medical reasons for federal disability? yes, can usps employee get retirement?, claims against the government after refusing fers disability retirement, dod civilian disability retirement lawyer, federal employee and hernia injury, federal employee early retirement terminal illness, federal employee not fit for duty and what are his options, fers and disability for cancer, fers disability retirement and reasonable accommodation, fers retirement application sf 3107 forms help, harassment and bullying of federal employee with disabilities, how to request reconsideration from opm, md letter for disability retirement help, medical retirement bop lawyer, medical retirement for federal employees, memorandum of record hostile work environment in case I decided to file for disability retirement in the future, metastatic cancer and other conditions on federal disability retirement from federal service, need help with my fers disability retirement, no opm disability list (that’s a ssdi term which won’t apply to opm med retirement), opm adverse action regulations owcp lawyer guide, opm disability laws and harrasment against forcing employees to resign, opm disability pension resign from federal government, opm disability reconsideration processing lawyer, opm disability retirement and va disability, opm gov excessive absenteeism due to medical conditions, opm leave of absence for long term medical condition, opm medical retirement request, opm poly on applying disability retirement, opm stress and reasonable accommodation before medical retirement, personal statement for fers security disability retirement, postal opm disability benefits, ps form 50 disability retirement, removed from government service due to continuous medical condition, requesting medical documentation for mspb disability case, second opinion to owcp and plan b, sf 3107 application in disability retirement, sf 3112 disability application package, standard form 3112 for disability, standard form 3112b fillable, va employee disability retirement attorney, va employee medical retirement benefits, when doctor will not write a narrative for owcp or opm, why us postal service disability taxable? if total income is low most won’t, write a letter to federal employer to change position because of disability and start planning and preparing case for a possible medical retirement with a fers lawyer | Leave a comment »