“What if” questions are rarely useful in applying the law, except in a preparatory manner for cross-examination purposes. No one likes surprises, and to prepare for every potentiality, eventuality, and “what if” scenario is a good idea — but only in a theoretical sense.
In preparing, formulating and filing a Federal Disability Retirement application under FERS or CSRS, the “what if” questions will inevitably arise — What if my Supervisor writes X? What if OPM asks Y? What if… ? The problem with “what if” questions is not in the asking of such questions (for asking them requires contemplation of a potential problem, which may propel preparation to an eventuality); rather, the problem occurs if one attempts to preempt a problem which may potentially exits but never realize its actuality.
If one preempts a non-occurrence, then what one has done is to wave a red flag and notify the Office of Personnel Management of the problem by bringing up the problem in the first place. That is often the very essence of the difficulties one finds in the preparation of the Applicant’s Statement of Disability, where the applicant fills out the SF 3112A as if it is a stream of consciousness opportunity to present to the Office of Personnel Management every problem known to man.
Preemption is fine for preparation; it needs to be answered and applied with great discretion.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Filed under: Theory and Practice: Tips and Strategies for a Successful Application | Tagged: addressing some potential issues in advance without waving the red flag, attorney representing federal workers for disability throughout the united states, civil service disability retirement, disability retirement for federal employees, federal disability law blog, federal opm disability tips for non-lawyers, filing for OPM disability retirement, how to defeat your federal disability retirement application, how to prepare a successful opm disability claim, identifying and preempting only real potential problems in the 3112a form, law firm representing clients in opm disability law all across america, learn the secrets of winning opm disability even after initial denials, legal representation for injured federal workers, making an effort to preempt opm's future legal arguments, nationwide representation of federal employees, postal service disability retirement, practical decision making: issues to consider before submitting a fers disability claim, preempting future problems with your federal disability application, preventing potential issues in your federal disability claim, the federal disabled worker and potential problems that the opm should never be aware of, the non-lawyers' guide to opm disability law, the problem of overwhelming ourselves with different what-if scenarios, tips for us government employees on disability retirement, USPS disability retirement, USPS disability retirement benefits, usps disability retirement blog, what issues to avoid during the formulation of the federal disability application, what issues to avoid during the preparation of the fers disability retirement application, what not to write in the 3112a, when preventing potential problems in a fers disability claim may become the problem itself, worrying about problems that will never occur during the fers disability process | Leave a comment »